Generative AI can Not yet Reliably Read and Extract Information from Clinical Notes in Medical Records

It may someday be possible to use Large Language Models (LLM) to automatically read clinical notes in medical records and reliably and efficiently extract relevant information to support patient care or research. But recent research from Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health using ChatGPT-4 to read medical notes from Emergency Department admissions to determine whether injured scooter and bicycle riders were wearing a helmet finds that LLM can't yet do this reliably. The findings are published in JAMA Network Open.

In a study of 54,569 emergency department visits among patients injured while riding a bicycle, scooter or other micromobility conveyance from 2019 to 2022, the AI LLM had difficulty replicating results of a text string–search based approach for extracting helmet status from clinical notes. The LLM only performed well when the prompt included all of the text used in the text string search-based approach. The LLM also had difficulty replicating its work across trials on each of five successive days, it did better t replicating its hallucinations than its accurate work. It particularly struggled when phrases were negated, such as reading "w/o helmet" or "unhelmeted" and reporting that the patient wore a helmet.

Large amounts of medically relevant data are included in electronic medical records in the form of written clinical notes, a type of unstructured data. Efficient ways to read and extract information from these notes would be extremely useful for research. Currently information from these clinical notes can be extracted using simple string-matching text search approaches or through more sophisticated artificial intelligence (AI)-based approaches such as natural language processing. The hope was that new LLM, such as ChatGPT-4, could extract information faster and more reliably.

"While we see potential efficiency gains in using the generative AI LLM for information extraction tasks, issues of reliability and hallucinations currently limit its utility," said Andrew Rundle, DrPH, professor of Epidemiology at Columbia Mailman School and senior author. "When we used highly detailed prompts that included all of the text strings related to helmets, on some days ChatGPT-4 could extract accurate data from the clinical notes. But the time required to define and test all of the text that had to be included in the prompt and ChatGPT-4's inability to replicate its work, day after day, indicates to us that ChatGPT-4 was not yet up to this task."

Using publicly available 2019 to 2022 data from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission's National Electronic Injury Surveillance System, a sample of 96 U.S. hospitals, Rundle and colleagues analyzed emergency department records of patients injured in e-bike, bicycle, hoverboard, and powered scooter accidents. They compared the results of ChatGPT-4's analyses of the records to data generated using more traditional text-string-based searches, and for 400 records, they compared ChatGPT's analyses to their own reading of the clinical notes in the records.

This research builds on their work studying how to prevent injuries among micromobility users (i.e. bicyclists, e-bike riders, scooter riders). "Helmet use is a key factor in injury severity, yet in most emergency department medical records and incident reports information on helmet use is buried in the clinical notes written by the physician or EMS respondent. There is a significant research need to be able to reliably and efficiently access this information." said Kathryn Burford, the lead author on the paper and a post-doctoral fellow in the Department of Epidemiology at the Mailman School.

"Our study examined the potential of an LLM for extracting information from clinical notes, a rich source of information for health professionals and researchers," said Rundle. "But at the time we used ChatGPT-4 it could not reliably provide us with data."

Burford KG, Itzkowitz NG, Ortega AG, Teitler JO, Rundle AG.
Use of Generative AI to Identify Helmet Status Among Patients With Micromobility-Related Injuries From Unstructured Clinical Notes.
JAMA Netw Open. 2024 Aug 1;7(8):e2425981. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.25981

Most Popular Now

Unlocking the 10 Year Health Plan

The government's plan for the NHS is a huge document. Jane Stephenson, chief executive of SPARK TSL, argues the key to unlocking its digital ambitions is to consider what it...

Alcidion Grows Top Talent in the UK, wit…

Alcidion has today announced the addition of three new appointments to their UK-based team, with one internal promotion and two external recruits. Dr Paul Deffley has been announced as the...

AI can Find Cancer Pathologists Miss

Men assessed as healthy after a pathologist analyses their tissue sample may still have an early form of prostate cancer. Using AI, researchers at Uppsala University have been able to...

New Training Year Starts at Siemens Heal…

In September, 197 school graduates will start their vocational training or dual studies in Germany at Siemens Healthineers. 117 apprentices and 80 dual students will begin their careers at Siemens...

AI, Full Automation could Expand Artific…

Automated insulin delivery (AID) systems such as the UVA Health-developed artificial pancreas could help more type 1 diabetes patients if the devices become fully automated, according to a new review...

How AI could Speed the Development of RN…

Using artificial intelligence (AI), MIT researchers have come up with a new way to design nanoparticles that can more efficiently deliver RNA vaccines and other types of RNA therapies. After training...

MIT Researchers Use Generative AI to Des…

With help from artificial intelligence, MIT researchers have designed novel antibiotics that can combat two hard-to-treat infections: drug-resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae and multi-drug-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Using generative AI algorithms, the research...

AI Hybrid Strategy Improves Mammogram In…

A hybrid reading strategy for screening mammography, developed by Dutch researchers and deployed retrospectively to more than 40,000 exams, reduced radiologist workload by 38% without changing recall or cancer detection...

Penn Developed AI Tools and Datasets Hel…

Doctors treating kidney disease have long depended on trial-and-error to find the best therapies for individual patients. Now, new artificial intelligence (AI) tools developed by researchers in the Perelman School...

Are You Eligible for a Clinical Trial? C…

A new study in the academic journal Machine Learning: Health discovers that ChatGPT can accelerate patient screening for clinical trials, showing promise in reducing delays and improving trial success rates. Researchers...

Global Study Reveals How Patients View M…

How physicians feel about artificial intelligence (AI) in medicine has been studied many times. But what do patients think? A team led by researchers at the Technical University of Munich...

New AI Tool Addresses Accuracy and Fairn…

A team of researchers at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai has developed a new method to identify and reduce biases in datasets used to train machine-learning algorithms...