Highland Marketing Advisory Board: How Do We Secure a 'Second Wave of Innovation' Post-COVID-19?

Highland MarketingThe Highland Marketing advisory board has been discussing the impact of the coronavirus outbreak on the deployment of health tech in the NHS.

At its March meeting, which took place just after UK prime minister Boris Johnson instructed people to "stay at home", members noted the rapid roll-out of remote working and virtual consultation tools, which are unlikely to be abandoned once the emergency is over.

But at its next meeting, which took place past the "peak" of the pandemic, they noted that many areas of NHS IT have remained untouched and argued that organisations could "slip back" unless structures, regulation, licencing and procurement are changed and, critically, funding is maintained.

They also argued that even if these issues are addressed, a "second wave" of innovation will be needed to create truly digital first pathways. So, at its June meeting, the board discussed some of the barriers start-ups, scale-ups and SMEs face in gaining a foothold in the UK health tech market.

Four big challenges

To inform its discussion, the meeting opened with a presentation from Hassan Chaudhury, digital health lead for Healthcare UK at the Department for International Trade.

In his day job, he has two roles: to help UK companies that want to export abroad, and to health overseas companies that want to work in the UK. In the second of these roles, Chaudhury said he found companies typically encountered four barriers:

One: Navigation is hard: Chaudhury pointed out that the NHS is referred to as 'a' health service, when each of the four countries of the UK has its own version. The English NHS is the biggest market but the most complex, with an evolving set of planning, commissioning, and provider bodies, and an even more complex regulatory regime.

Two: Commercial models: Chaudhury argued that too many companies "have an idea, then develop a product, and then try and sell it to a customer", while keeping themselves going with multiple investor funding rounds.

More companies, he argued, should develop an idea or product with a customer in mind, and think-through how the customer is going to pay for their services. He noted that some of the best-known digital consultation companies focused on the insurance market, which has both a clear need and a clear payment model, before turning to the NHS.

Three: Pilotitis: Chaudhury pointed out that "there is a lot of parochialism" in the NHS; and that even when a company that has made an idea work in, say, Dorset it will be often asked to prove again that it will work in, say Newcastle.

This is one reason the NHS’ existing incubator and accelerator schemes have a patchy record. Even if they get something working in one part of their patch, there is no guarantee the rest of the patch will take it.

Four: The digital alphabet soup: If the NHS is complex, then its digital space is byzantine: the DHCS, NHSE/I, PHE, other arms-length bodies, NHSX and NHS Digital all have roles, but it’s far from clear how they operate in practice.

At worst, Chaudhury said, they “all bring in their own innovations” – an issue that has become a significant problem during the coronavirus outbreak, as departments and ALBs have turned to their own contact books of (usually) large suppliers.

Sounds familiar...

All of these issues were familiar to the board. Chair Jeremy Nettle said that when he worked for techUK, he often told newbies that "the N in NHS stands for numerous" and "go from there as in procurement terms there is no central NHS procurement structure to work with."

While Andy Kinnear, the former chief digital officer of NHS South Central and West Commissioning Support Unit, argued that the 2012 Lansley reforms had created a "particularly complicated version" of the NHS in England.

The advisory board has said repeatedly that it would like to see the re-introduction of effective, regional structures to reduce fragmentation and drive decision making. But even if they emerge, they will take time to find their feet.

James Norman, healthcare chief information officer, EMEA, DellEMC, noted that this was one of the issues with the digital alphabet soup; the two organisations at the heart of it, NHSX and NHS Digital, "are still trying to define their roles."

Ravi Kumar, an entrepreneur himself, went so far as to say that while the NHS could look like an attractive health tech prospect, appearances could be deceptive. On the upside, he argued, any company that could make it through would be “hardened” and ready for any export opportunity going; and investors do still like to see NHS success.

What’s the way forward?

So, what are the solutions? Kinnear argued that whatever the organisation of the NHS, there will always be a mix of people working within its organisations; some risk averse, some innovators; some into 'big tech' some up for working with SMEs.

The trick for new entrants and start-ups, he argued, is to find the people who want to work with them. Nicola Haywood-Alexander, a public sector CIO and new member of the board, said it would help if the NHS invested in these individuals.

In particular, she suggested, NHS IT needs to invest in making its leaders more confident about building data architectures and demanding digital that is designed to deliver a good experience for the user of the technology.

Big tech is not the enemy - and may be a good friend

Norman took a slightly different tack. He argued that in other sectors a well-established commercial model for smaller suppliers is to work with 'big tech' firms that have the heft and resources to deal with complex regulatory regimes, procurement processes, and customer landscapes.

Some health tech companies should take the same approach, he argued, and "get embedded with someone big enough to deal with all the hassle that the NHS is going to throw at them."

Andrena Logue, a consultant based in Northern Ireland, agreed with this. However, she pointed out that while Northern Ireland has a vibrant university, research and start-up sector, companies often look to the US before they look to the UK for growth. So there is still a need to make it easier for health tech companies of all sizes to sell into the NHS.

One idea that hadn’t yet been discussed, she suggested, would be to refocus on digital maturity, which was started to gain some attention before the coronavirus hit. If there was more transparency about the digital maturity of different trusts and healthcare economies, she argued, it would be easier for companies to see where their ideas would work.

All business is local

Chaudhury felt there was "violent agreement" around the table about the issues. And if there was one, further thing that the advisory board agreed on, it was that innovation would not be driven by national bodies or networks outside the NHS' normal operations.

Because, as Kinnear pointed out, they are not the ones who need what companies have to offer and they can't deliver them customers. As Logue put it, innovators need to "cut out the middlemen." Develop a business model, "get to localities and individuals and prove it." "That will go a long way to resolving a lot of these issues."

About the Highland Marketing advisory board

The Highland Marketing advisory board is: Jeremy Nettle (chair), formerly of Oracle and techUK, Cindy Fedell, chief digital and information officer at Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Andy Kinnear, former director of digital transformation at NHS South, Central and West Commissioning Support Unit, Ravi Kumar, health tech entrepreneur and chair of ZANEC, Andrena Logue, consultant, Experiential HealthTech, and James Norman, healthcare CIO, EMEA, at DellEMC.

About Highland Marketing

Highland Marketing is an integrated communications, PR and marketing consultancy with an unrivalled reputation for supporting UK and international health tech organisations. Highland Marketing is dedicated to supporting the diffusion and adoption of innovation across health and social care, and over nearly 20 years has built a reputation for being the go-to agency for vendors and their customers. Highland Marketing is expert in market strategy planning, research, branding, messaging, content marketing, PR, social media and scales acceleration.

Most Popular Now

AI can Detect COVID-19 in the Lungs Like…

A University of Central Florida researcher is part of a new study showing that artificial intelligence can be nearly as accurate as a physician in diagnosing COVID-19 in the lungs. The...

New Research Reveals Impact of COVID-19 …

Hospitals face new demand for virtual visiting, and more patients are confident they don't always need to see a doctor in person, as the use of remote technologies rise. But...

Telemedicine Saves Chronic Pain Patients…

Patients who saw a pain medicine specialist via telemedicine saved time and money and were highly satisfied with their experience, even before the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a study being...

Black Country Pathology Services Deliver…

Black Country Pathology Services has pushed ahead with a major initiative to create a laboratory network to serve four trusts and delivered a successful go-live for its CliniSys laboratory information...

Greater Manchester and Sectra Sign Deal …

Eight NHS hospital trusts in Greater Manchester are to benefit from medical imaging technology that will transform how doctors and other NHS healthcare professionals access and review images from patient...

North Bristol NHS Clinicians Go Live in …

North Bristol NHS Trust has successfully and safely fast-tracked the roll out of a series of digital tools to clinicians to help in their response to COVID-19. Over 3,500 clinicians went...

The Walton Centre Extends 17-Year-Long R…

The Walton Centre NHS Foundation Trust has renewed its contract with Silverlink Software, to retain the use of one of the country's leading patient administration systems (PAS), supporting the trust’s...

Allscripts Continues to Lead in Interope…

Allscripts (NASDAQ: MDRX) remains committed to effective interoperability in healthcare delivery. A leader in interoperability and open platforms, the company has made it a priority to deliver clinicians accessible, clinically...

Philips Partners with LeQuest to Provide…

Royal Philips (NYSE: PHG, AEX: PHIA), a global leader in health technology, and LeQuest, a leading provider of online interactive simulation-based training for the use of medical devices [1], today...

New Fluoroscopy System from Siemens Heal…

Siemens Healthineers is debuting its new fluoroscopy system, the Luminos Lotus Max, at the annual French JFR 2020. The system offers industry-leading technology in radiography and fluoroscopy. "Combining these state-of-the-art...

Depression in Teenagers Prompts Pioneeri…

Teenagers starting their GCSE and A level studies are being treated for depression through a new digital mental health therapy programme for young people that reflects the increasing education pressures...